Workplace injuries aren’t always something you can see on an X-ray. Sometimes what happens at work breaks something inside you instead. We’ve handled cases at Joseph Law Group, LLC where clients developed severe PTSD, crippling anxiety, and depression that made it impossible to function. All because of something that happened on the job.
And yes, these injuries can qualify for workers’ compensation in Ohio. But I’m not going to sugarcoat it. These claims are tough.
What Ohio Actually Considers A Compensable Mental Health Injury
The workers’ compensation system recognizes psychological injuries. That’s the good news. The bad news? They hold you to a much higher standard than they do for physical injuries.
You can’t just say work is stressful and expect the Ohio Bureau of Workers’ Compensation to cut you a check. That won’t fly. What you need is proof that a specific traumatic event at work caused your mental health condition.
The cases we see approved usually involve serious trauma:
- You witnessed a coworker die or get catastrophically injured
- Someone assaulted you at work
- You developed PTSD after a violent incident
- Your mental health collapsed after suffering a severe physical injury on the job
General workplace stress doesn’t qualify. Neither does having a difficult boss or feeling overwhelmed by your job responsibilities. I know that sounds harsh, but Ohio law draws a clear line between everyday work pressures and actual psychological trauma that deserves compensation.
The Physical-Mental Connection Makes All The Difference
If you got physically injured first and then developed psychological problems because of that injury, your case gets treated very differently. Much more favorably, actually. Let’s say you were in a serious machinery accident and lost part of your hand. Six months later, you’re dealing with depression and severe anxiety about going back to work. Those mental health issues can be covered as part of your original workers’ comp claim.
Why? Because they stem from a compensable physical injury that nobody disputes happened at work. Pure psychological claims are harder. When there’s no physical injury involved, the BWC scrutinizes everything. They’ll question whether it really happened the way you said. They’ll look for pre-existing conditions. They’ll argue your personal life caused the problem, not work.
You Need Bulletproof Documentation
The BWC wants clear evidence that your psychological condition came from your job. Anything vague or uncertain in your documentation gives them a reason to deny you. And they will.
What actually helps your case:
- Reporting the incident immediately when it happened, preferably in writing
- Getting diagnosed by a psychiatrist or psychologist who specializes in trauma
- Medical records that explicitly connect your condition to the workplace event
- Witness statements from coworkers who saw what happened
- A clean mental health history before the incident
Your doctor needs to be direct about causation. If their notes say something wishy-washy like “patient’s anxiety could be related to workplace stress,” that’s not enough. You need documentation stating clearly that the traumatic event at work caused your condition.
Why The BWC Denies These Claims
Mental health workers’ comp claims get denied at a much higher rate than physical injury claims. Sometimes it’s because the documentation isn’t strong enough. Other times, it’s because adjusters simply don’t take psychological injuries as seriously as broken bones.
We see denials based on delayed reporting, insufficient medical evidence, pre-existing mental health treatment in your records, or the BWC arguing there wasn’t a specific traumatic event. Sometimes they’ll claim your marriage problems or financial stress caused your depression, not work.
You can appeal. Actually, you should appeal if you believe your claim is legitimate. A Cleveland Workers’ Compensation Attorney can review why they denied you and help build a stronger case. Sometimes that means getting a second medical opinion. Sometimes it means finding witnesses you didn’t know you had. Sometimes it’s just presenting the same evidence in a way that’s harder for the BWC to ignore.
What Gets Covered If You Win
Once your claim is approved, the BWC should cover treatment related to your work-caused psychological condition. That means therapy sessions, psychiatric appointments, and medications your doctor prescribes.
You might also qualify for wage replacement benefits if you can’t work because of your mental health. How long those benefits last depends on what your doctors say about your recovery and your ability to return to employment. Can you get permanent disability for a psychological injury? Yes, but it’s evaluated differently from physical impairments. You’ll need extensive medical documentation proving your condition is severe and long-lasting.
These Cases Need Legal Help
I’m going to be straight with you. Mental health workers’ comp claims are complicated. Insurance companies fight them hard because psychological injuries are easier to question than physical ones. They’ll bring in their own doctors. They’ll comb through your entire medical history looking for anything they can use against you.
What happened to you at work matters. Your psychological injuries deserve the same recognition and compensation as someone who threw out their back or broke their leg. At Joseph Law Group, LLC, we work with mental health professionals who know how to document these conditions properly. As a Cleveland Workers’ Compensation Attorney firm, we’ve handled these cases before. We know what the BWC looks for and what kinds of evidence actually move the needle. If you’ve developed a mental health condition because of something that happened at your job, call us. We’ll sit down, talk through what happened, and figure out whether you’ve got a case worth pursuing under Ohio law.
